David Narvaez: My Trust Issues
Abstract: In the program of formalizing all of mathematics, Lean 4 has emerged as the lingua franca of interactive theorem proving. In particular, the Mathlib project, tightly developed with Lean 4 itself, has a major influence on the organization and visibility of formalized mathematics. Naturally, the design decisions behind Mathlib will affect the perception of formalization projects not only within the Lean 4 sphere but also in the field of interactive theorem proving as a whole. One such decision is leaving the code compiler out of the allowed trust base, effectively excluding computational results from the library. This decision leaves out a large class of mathematical knowledge for which we only know mechanized proofs.
In this talk we will explore some examples of how this issue creeps into the public perception and the peer-review process, and what types of results are affected by it.
Seminar website: https://mathematical-conversations.splet.arnes.si/